ARCHIVED RESEARCH PROJECT · completed 2026-09-25 · Which 16 consequential f1r segmentation cases should be accepted, rejected or kept separate? · Back to Home

PROJECT SUMMARY

QuestionWhich 16 consequential f1r segmentation cases should be accepted, rejected or kept separate?
Method12 G decisions: old f1r_v003 boundaries rejected as unreliable/contaminated/truncated. No new boundary is accepted: O00049, O00173, O00182, O00189, O00233, O00305, O00313, O00352, O00392, O00433, O00445, O00473.2 C decisions: f1r_v003 O00215 and O00446 have their old single whole-form proposals rejected in favor of spatial separation. Each is represented by two separate line-associated spatial candidates, for four regions total. This is not a count of linguistic glyphs. Existing native component support within the registered old fields supplies provisional spatial envelopes and masks. Specific line IDs, exact extents and pixel ownership remain unapproved; all residual/shared threshold material and the full old fields are retained.2 D decisions, one candidate: f1r_v003 O00044 and O00045 are retained separately as FC0001 and FC0002 and jointly represented by JC0001 / provisional C0001. O00046 is explicitly excluded. The joint viewing rectangle is the union of the two registered fragment fields, not an accepted complete-form outline. Its wider context shows the upper structure without automatically assigning it or neighboring marks to the candidate.The 601 independent native v004 proposals, their distinct visual IDs, 27 lines, 189 clusters, component masks, 304 unselected partitions, spacing, R1–R4 and existing uncertainty flags are inherited unchanged. The v005 observation wrappers identify their v004 provenance; this does not approve them.No recurring forms were merged; no linguistic identity, sound, meaning, glyph count or new automatic boundary was accepted. Parameters and thresholds were unchanged.
Important numbers16 human-reviewed case
Finding and conclusion12 G decisions: old f1r_v003 boundaries rejected as unreliable/contaminated/truncated. No new boundary is accepted: O00049, O00173, O00182, O00189, O00233, O00305, O00313, O00352, O00392, O00433, O00445, O00473.2 C decisions: f1r_v003 O00215 and O00446 have their old single whole-form proposals rejected in favor of spatial separation. Each is represented by two separate line-associated spatial candidates, for four regions total. This is not a count of linguistic glyphs. Existing native component support within the registered old fields supplies provisional spatial envelopes and masks. Specific line IDs, exact extents and pixel ownership remain unapproved; all residual/shared threshold material and the full old fields are retained.2 D decisions, one candidate: f1r_v003 O00044 and O00045 are retained separately as FC0001 and FC0002 and jointly represented by JC0001 / provisional C0001. O00046 is explicitly excluded. The joint viewing rectangle is the union of the two registered fragment fields, not an accepted complete-form outline. Its wider context shows the upper structure without automatically assigning it or neighboring marks to the candidate.The 601 independent native v004 proposals, their distinct visual IDs, 27 lines, 189 clusters, component masks, 304 unselected partitions, spacing, R1–R4 and existing uncertainty flags are inherited unchanged. The v005 observation wrappers identify their v004 provenance; this does not approve them.No recurring forms were merged; no linguistic identity, sound, meaning, glyph count or new automatic boundary was accepted. Parameters and thresholds were unchanged.
Limits- Replacement extents for all 12 rejected G boundaries. - Exact boundaries, stroke ownership and glyph count inside both spatial regions of each C case. Component-based candidate masks implement the approved separation principle but have not been traced or accepted by the reviewers. -…
MeaningReplacement extents for all 12 rejected G boundaries.Exact boundaries, stroke ownership and glyph count inside both spatial regions of each C case. Component-based candidate masks implement the approved separation principle but have not been traced or accepted by the reviewers.Complete form extent, loop/crossbar membership and identity of the O00044/O00045 joint candidate. O00046 stays separate and retains its prior F assessment.All other 472 comparison cases have no new human decision: 20 A, 171 B and 281 F assistant assessments remain at their previous status. The two D approvals do not upgrade O00046.All 601 native visual classes remain unassessed. Existing flags remain: 232 low-confidence segmentations, 73 threshold-sensitive observations, 276 possible compounds, 384 neighbor-dependent segmentations, 185 uncertain line assignments and 300 repeated-stroke candidates. These overlapping counts are not mutually exclusive.All 304 automatic partition hypotheses remain unselected. Minim counts, gallows structure, variant relationships, shared/connected strokes and semantic component decomposition remain unresolved unless covered by the narrow spatial decisions above.R1–R4 layout remains unchanged, including R4's unresolved automatic line attachment and the unresolved R2 tall-form ownership case.Whether f1r is sufficiently calibrated to authorize further extraction is a separate, ungranted approval.

Read the findings preserved from this completed study.

EXPLORE ALL RESULTS

16 accessible result rows from 16 authoritative meaningful result rows in the declared scope. Review cards are separate.

All rows from the stated saved result sets are accessible; detailed machine arrays remain in the linked source files.

REVIEW NEEDED

16 preserved review panels are available below.

This curated view is separate from the complete meaningful results listed above.

internal_patterns_v001 · First manuscript-wide internal pattern survey complete; human inspection current

HISTORICAL CODEX RECOMMENDATIONS · SCOPED DECISIONS RECORDED

The consequential cases

16 historical recommendations. Scoped decisions have now been recorded in the reviewed version: reject old G boundaries only; represent C spatial separation without glyph counts; retain O00044/O00045 separately and jointly, excluding O00046. No new boundary is accepted.

16 cases

f1r_v003:G0044 · O00044

D · Likely needs merging with neighbor

The narrow fragments O00044 and O00045 are the two faint stems under a shared upper loop/crossbar structure. Inspect a joint whole-form alternative while retaining the two components. Neighboring O00046 is excluded from this merge proposal. No compound identity is accepted.

Old source crop
O00044 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00044 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00044 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0045 · O00045

D · Likely needs merging with neighbor

The narrow fragments O00044 and O00045 are the two faint stems under a shared upper loop/crossbar structure. Inspect a joint whole-form alternative while retaining the two components. Neighboring O00046 is excluded from this merge proposal. No compound identity is accepted.

Old source crop
O00045 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00045 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00045 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0049 · O00049

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00049 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00049 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00049 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0173 · O00173

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00173 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00173 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00173 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0182 · O00182

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00182 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00182 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00182 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0189 · O00189

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00189 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00189 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00189 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0215 · O00215

C · Likely needs splitting

The old tall crop contains two separated horizontal writing bands. A vertical partition by line is likely needed; the unit count within either band is unresolved.

Old source crop
O00215 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00215 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00215 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0233 · O00233

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00233 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00233 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00233 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0305 · O00305

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00305 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00305 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00305 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0313 · O00313

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00313 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00313 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00313 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0352 · O00352

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00352 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00352 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00352 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0392 · O00392

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00392 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00392 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00392 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0433 · O00433

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00433 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00433 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00433 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0445 · O00445

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00445 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00445 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00445 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0446 · O00446

C · Likely needs splitting

The old crop includes the lower part of one tall structure and the upper part of another on the line below. Preserve two line-associated spatial candidates rather than accepting one whole form.

Old source crop
O00446 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00446 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00446 — Wider native context

f1r_v003:G0473 · O00473

G · Old boundary likely incorrect

Wider source context shows writing from adjacent rows or a clipped tall structure inside the old field. The old whole-form boundary is likely contaminated or truncated; the new automatic boundary is not thereby accepted.

Old source crop
O00473 — Old source crop
Native Yale crop
O00473 — Native Yale crop
Wider native context
O00473 — Wider native context

FINDINGS FROM THE COMPLETED STUDY · public presentation of [preserved evidence reference]

f1r_v005 — scoped human review applied

The 16 consequential-case decisions reported by Jeremy, with reviewer names Jeremy and ChatGPT, are recorded as HUMAN-APPROVED REVIEW DECISIONS. This is a reviewed overlay on frozen f1r_v004, not a new extraction. Full-f1r calibration approval and full-manuscript extraction remain blocked pending a separate decision.

Exactly what changed

All IDs in the approval table are f1r_v003 observation IDs. Matching numbers in the native v004/v005 inventory are different records and were not edited by number.

Old observationCategoryHuman-approved actionReviewed representation
O00044Drepresent joint whole form candidate onlyJC0001
O00045Drepresent joint whole form candidate onlyJC0001
O00049Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00049
O00173Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00173
O00182Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00182
O00189Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00189
O00215Csplit spatially by line onlyREVIEW_O00215
O00233Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00233
O00305Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00305
O00313Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00313
O00352Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00352
O00392Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00392
O00433Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00433
O00445Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00445
O00446Csplit spatially by line onlyREVIEW_O00446
O00473Greject old boundary onlyREVIEW_O00473

Exactly what remains unresolved

Provenance and review

· · · Frozen parent v004 review

The chain for every approved case is original version-qualified observation → hash-bound frozen Codex recommendation → explicitly scoped human decision → resulting reviewed representation. The source remains Yale image 1006076, 2972 × 3766. New RGB crops are exact unresampled source rectangles; support masks are labeled derived aids. No human browser drafts were migrated.